#WhyIStay #MfAProud

So this afternoon, I had an experience that reminded me why I love to teach math to middle school students. I’m a pretty patient guy, and I am a big believer in Jo Boaler’s ideas about depth and not speed and growth mindset. I have no issues with students who need more time to master ideas and concepts, and I’m often at school late and available to help.

In my 7th grade classes, today we took a quiz on operations with rational numbers: fractions, decimals, and mixed numbers were being added, subtracted, multiplied, and divided (including in yucky complicated fractions with expressions in the numerators and denominators). One of my students is a little bit anxious about math – his mom confessed to me at parent/teacher conferences that he often can’t sleep the night before a test or a quiz. Today, when the quiz ended, he seemed upset and asked, “Can I see you after school today?” and I clarified, “Do you need more time on the quiz?” and he said no, I just want to talk to you about it because I don’t think I did very well. I said okay, and he went off to 8th period.

Meanwhile, I had a prep 8th period, so I decided to start grading the quizzes from his class, and I was in the middle of grading his quiz when he returned after dismissal. I finished grading it, and we reviewed the mistakes. Some were silly mistakes – like 21 – 13 = 7 (which he admitted rushing through) or losing a negative in a few places. We checked out a minor calculation error in one of the problems, and then we addressed a major conceptual misunderstanding of dealing with subtracting involving going from positive to negative when there were fractions involved. For example, if we do 5 3/4 – 9 1/2, he was getting – 4 1/4, which is not correct. It should be -3 3/4. I drew a number line and we did it in stages:

start at 5 3/4, go back 5 to 3/4. Then go back 1 to -1/4. Then go back another 3 to – 3 1/4. That’s -9, and now go back 1/2 to -3 3/4.

Alternatively, we talked about how you could subtract the whole numbers and the fractions separately, but keeping their signs:

(5 – 9) + (3/4 – 1/2)

-4 + 1/4 = -3 3/4

From this, I even shared with him that I did a problem like this on the board in the other 7th grade class and I actually messed it up because I always get a little turned around right by the 0 (when we switch from having + 3/4 to having – 1/4), so that’s why on my number line, I jump down by the whole number part to +3/4, then jump by 1 to cross the 0, and then jump the rest of the whole number part.

He seemed thankful that I had explained things clearly to him – and he was clearly understanding the math better – but he was still nervous/upset about the grade on the quiz (which by the way, was an 18/25, a 72%). He said “What can I do about the quiz grade?” and seemed near tears. I decided I would let him redo the quiz right then and there. So I handed him the other version of the quiz (I always do two versions to avoid students copying) and he confidently redid it. His new score is a 23/25 because he only had one minor error – everything else was completely correct (He left without seeing his new score, but just knowing that he felt more confident about it).

I came home to find this email in my inbox:

Dear Mr. G,

I would just like you to know how much it meant to me today when you let me retake our rational number quiz after school. This year has been really different from last year because of the many times you have sat down with me after school, and helped me with what I have been having trouble with. Last year I had a math teacher who wasn’t the nicest person. So with that, and math not being my strongest subject, math was kind of a struggle. I would just like you to know how much I appreciate all of this, and how much this is affecting me in a positive way.

Thanks, <student name>

The positive impact I had on him from something so simple as spending 15 minutes explaining a concept to him one-on-one, the fact that I’m sending him the message that we’re not done learning math when the first quiz happens, the fact that I’m starting to change his mindset from fixed to growth – all of these are why I stay. I feel appreciated by my students this year, and I love them all so much.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s